Thinking as a Hobby 3477087 Curiosities served |
2003-03-04 11:27 AM Even More on the Pledge Previous Entry :: Next Entry Read/Post Comments (0) Matthew Yglesias, despite being an infidel, find the phrase "under god" fairly benign.
The bigger point, rather than that it's making a factual claim about our nation, is that it's making a factual claim about the existence of god. Thus, it very obviously contains religious content, and it's really to assert otherwise.
Well obviously I wouldn't. And I wouldn't want my children or anyone else's compelled to do so. If the majority of Americans want to perceive of this country as being lorded over by a deity, that's their right. But I shouldn't have to assent to the collective perception, or in this case pledge an oath that includes that ideal. Yglesias doesn't perceive it as an establishment of religion, and all along I've argued that it's more a violation of the free exercise clause of the First Amendment than the establishment clause. It's undue influence from the State. Would Yglesias, I wonder, have a problem with teacher-led prayer, as long as it was non-denominational? Read/Post Comments (0) Previous Entry :: Next Entry Back to Top |
||||||
© 2001-2010 JournalScape.com. All rights reserved. All content rights reserved by the author. custsupport@journalscape.com |