Thinking as a Hobby 3477334 Curiosities served |
2003-06-17 9:50 AM God = Love = No War Previous Entry :: Next Entry Read/Post Comments (16) Via Jill, here's an interesting Q&A by Chris Hedges, NY Times reporter, author of War Is a Force That Gives Us Meaning, and commencement ceremony boo-ee.
The first question asks when war is justified. He starts to respond by saying this:
So war is justified to: 1) Defend yourself. 2) Stop horrific acts of genocide and mass murder. Is that about right?
But wait a minute. Does the invasion of Kuwait qualify as either of the above conditions Hedges has already outlined as "the only times war can be justified"? We weren't defending ourselves, and though hundreds of Kuwait troops were killed in the invasion, Iraq's incursion into Kuwait could hardly be labeled genocide or mass murder, especially when stacked up against many other contemporary conflicts. So I'm confused by Hedges' remarks. Sounds to me like, using his own criteria, the first Gulf War wasn't justified. And then he's asked about love, and he answers:
This is the sort of mushy-headed stuff that sounds nice, but really says nothing at all. Note these two statements in particular: Love is the only antidote to war... and I do not see love, however, as an alternative to war. Huh? It's an antidote, but not an alternative. Whatever, Chris. This lets the author get away with sounding pseudo-profound, without actually offering anything substantive. Just love one another. M'kay. How about this? Education is a preventative measure against war. So is secularism. So is democracy. When was the last time two democracies went at it hammer-and-tongs? It's not some nebulous notion of love (how do you implement that policy-wise, anyway) that will lessen the cycles of violence. The answers are rationalism and freedom.
Oh brother. Can I get that on a bumper sticker? Read/Post Comments (16) Previous Entry :: Next Entry Back to Top |
||||||
© 2001-2010 JournalScape.com. All rights reserved. All content rights reserved by the author. custsupport@journalscape.com |