Thinking as a Hobby 3478346 Curiosities served |
2007-09-10 8:37 AM Liberal and Conservative Brains Previous Entry :: Next Entry Read/Post Comments (3) This is interesting, but as with anything cognitive, you have to be careful interpreting data and overgeneralizing, or assigning causality incorrectly.
They had 43 college student self-describe along the liberal/conservative continuum. Then they had them do a task in which they had to press a button if they saw an "M", and not press it if they say a "W". The letters were flashed very rapidly. During the task, they measured activity in the anterior cingulate cortex, which is implicated in decision making and conflict monitoring. There was apparently a statistical difference in the activity in this brain region between self-described liberals and conservatives, with the region being more activated on average in self-described liberals. The liberals were also more accurate on average. It's interesting that they found a difference, but again, you have to be careful interpreting this data, and you have to put forth a reasonable model of why it occurs. This doesn't stop media outlets from grabbing it and running with it, though.
Ummm...okay. I'm a bit confused about something, though. The task involved correctly inhibiting a particular motor response. Wouldn't we expect the opposite results? Wouldn't we expect liberals to display activity demonstrating less conflict, if they are supposed to be more open to new ideas? Wouldn't someone who is less rigid in their thinking be more prone to allow for mistakes? That's the problem with studies of this sort, that look at activity in a particular part of the brain whose function is poorly understood at best. Either side of the political spectrum could point to it to validate their views of the opposing party. Without a substantive understanding of exactly what's going on, it's silly to extrapolate very far at all. Besides, how would libertarians do? Read/Post Comments (3) Previous Entry :: Next Entry Back to Top |
||||||
© 2001-2010 JournalScape.com. All rights reserved. All content rights reserved by the author. custsupport@journalscape.com |