Dude... I just got forwarded this site:

Once More with Hobbits

It's the songs from Buffy's Once More with Feeling, but redone in Lord of the Rings characters!

From I've Got a Theory

GANDALF:
I've got a theory that it's the One Ring
Seed of Sauron's power forged in the Cracks of Doom

ARAGORN:
I've got a theory that I'm the True King
Ruling Gondor from Anfalas to the Anduin

or from I'll Never Tell

LEGOLAS:
Look it's a dwarf, he's uncouth and he's coarse
A terrible boor
He makes this run 'cross the wide plains of Ro-han
Hard to endure
The hobbits must be saved
But you'd think he'd find time to shave
I'll take it to my grave . . .
I'll never tell

GIMLI:
Great, it's an elf who's obsessed with himself
Now there's a surprise
I can detect all his sly disrespect
Because he's stiff-necked
So he can run on snow
His only weapon's that dumb bow
There's just one thing that - no
I'll never tell